| Past Masters |
Years Served |
| Fred C. Beecher |
1915 – 1916 |
| Lindley H. Dennis |
1917 |
| Walter M. Mumma |
1918 |
| John E. Sweeney |
1919 |
| F.A. Lovell Harrison |
1920 |
| Edward N. Cooper |
1921 |
| William S. McMonigle |
1922 |
| Ralph E. Irwin |
1923 |
| James W. Milhoouse |
1924 |
| Carl K. Dean |
1925 |
| Roy M. Lechthaler |
1926 |
| H. Earl Faust |
1927 |
| Augustus C. Stailey |
1928 |
| Lloyd E. Hippensteel |
1929 |
| Adolph S. Benson |
1930 |
| Harry L. Baker |
1931 |
| Richard C. Batley |
1932 |
| John D. Weaver |
1933 |
| I. Guy Stickell |
1934 |
| William L. Fry |
1935 |
| Fredrick H. Reeser |
1936 |
| James C. Thompson |
1937 |
| William P. McHolland |
1938 |
| Daniel Pyffer, Jr. |
1939 |
| Benjamin H. Millard |
1940 |
| Donald R. Stone |
1941 |
| Frank I. Reynolds |
1942 |
| Bradford M. Fager |
1943 |
| Joseph H. Ross |
1944 |
| Joseph Danza |
1945 |
| Roy A. Snyder |
1946 |
| John R. Eldridge |
1947 |
| Paul B. Dohner |
1948 |
| Raymond Y. Herman |
1949 |
| Joseph W. Caveny |
1950 |
| Lester P. Reed |
1951 |
| George C. Hoopy |
1952 |
| William B. Gingrich |
1953 |
| George A. Hain |
1954 |
| G. Benjamin Adair |
1955 |
| Harry L. Parson |
1956 |
| Roger N. Brown |
1957 |
| Morris E. Swartz, Jr. |
1958 |
| Donald I. Rumney, Sr. |
1959 |
| Paul W. Baughman |
1960 |
| Havard C.B. Sellers |
1961 |
| Hubert A.B. Lee |
1962 |
| William M. Baker |
1963 |
| Verne L. Fleagle |
1964 |
| Robert W. Trawitz |
1965 |
| Paul E. Anderson |
1966 |
| Vivian S. King |
1967 |
| H. Eugene Wright |
1968 |
| Wendell S. Junkin |
1969 |
| Robert W. Snover |
1970 |
| Charles R. Miller |
1971 |
| Larry R. Adair |
1972 |
| Jack R. Wiles |
1973 |
| Edwin R. Junkin |
1974 |
| Robert L. Collins |
1975/1997 |
| Earl A. Leonhard |
1976 |
| John B. Hoffert |
1977 |
| George B. Yohe |
1978 |
| R. Stanley Viguers |
1979 |
| James S. Mackey, Jr. |
1980 |
| Rodney V. Houseal |
1981 |
| Glenn C. Evans |
1982 |
| Donald R. Harner |
1983 |
| Raymond H. Fosnot, Jr. |
1984 |
| Robert W. Burdick |
1985 |
| Richard A. Grove |
1986 |
| Brian E. Rabena |
1987 |
| Kenneth G. Puller, Jr. |
1988 |
| Keith A. Sultzbaugh |
1989 |
| William L. Walker |
1990 |
| Donald L. Shuler |
1991 |
| Richard C. Rupp |
1992 |
| Clyde M. McCrea |
1993 |
| John C. Davidson |
1994 |
| William C. Shadow II |
1995 |
| Russell L. Miller |
1996 |
| Donald L. Shuler, Jr. |
1998/2002/2012 |
| Richard L. Taylor |
1999 |
| Richard F. Miller, Jr. |
2000 |
| James R. Villott |
2001 |
| Stanley E. Johnson, Jr. |
2003 |
| Keith E. Murray |
2004/2005 |
| William E. Luta |
2006 |
| William D. Kautz |
2007/2008 |
| Michael R. Taylor |
2009 |
| J. Matthew Seagrist |
2010 |
| Douglas W. Hitz |
2011 |